DUI Defense Lawyer, Cincinnati OH

What Is ORC 4511.19? Operating A Vehicle Under The Influence of Alcohol or Drugs

ORC 4511.19 is Ohio’s operating a vehicle under the influence (OVI) statute, and the letters and numbers after it on your citation tell you exactly which version of the offense the State is charging. A citation for 4511.19(A)(1)(a) accuses you of driving while impaired. One for (A)(1)(d) or (A)(1)(h) points to a breath test number instead.

The Farrish Law Firm, L.P.A. defends OVI charges in Cincinnati and across Southwest Ohio, and attorney Kelly Farrish handles DUI and OVI cases exclusively. Match your subsection in the table that follows, then call +1 (513) 549-0611 for a free phone consultation about what the State will have to prove.

What Does My 4511.19 Subsection Mean?

Avvo Rating - Top Rated Criminal Defense

Each subsection of ORC 4511.19 describes a different way to commit OVI. Most divisions under (A)(1) are “per se” offenses. Per se is Latin for “by itself,” and here it means the test number alone is the violation. Division (A)(1)(a) is the exception, because it turns on impairment instead of a number.

Subsection What it covers Test level Penalty tier
(A)(1)(a) Driving under the influence of alcohol, drugs, or both No number required Low tier
(A)(1)(b) Whole blood alcohol .08 to under .17 Low tier
(A)(1)(c) Blood serum or plasma alcohol .096 to under .204 Low tier
(A)(1)(d) Breath alcohol .08 to under .17 Low tier
(A)(1)(e) Urine alcohol .11 to under .238 Low tier
(A)(1)(f) Whole blood alcohol .17 or more High tier
(A)(1)(g) Blood serum or plasma alcohol .204 or more High tier
(A)(1)(h) Breath alcohol .17 or more High tier
(A)(1)(i) Urine alcohol .238 or more High tier
(A)(1)(j) Listed drugs or drug metabolites Set levels per drug Low tier
(A)(2) Refusing a test with a prior OVI within 20 years Refusal High tier
(B) Drivers under 21 .02 to under .08 (blood or breath) Separate offense

Breath results are measured in grams of alcohol per 210 liters of breath. Blood results are a percentage by weight. People call both of them BAC (blood alcohol concentration), and the .08 and .17 lines apply to each.

The full text is published by the Ohio Legislative Service Commission at codes.ohio.gov.

Why does my ticket list two subsections?

Many Ohio OVI citations charge (A)(1)(a) together with one per se subsection, such as (A)(1)(d) for a breath test. The State files both so it has a fallback if one theory weakens.

A single incident still leads to one OVI conviction and one sentence, and the per se count usually decides whether the case is sentenced as low tier or high tier.

How Is 4511.19(A)(1)(a) Different From a Per Se Charge?

The handcuffs with a gavel

The difference is what the prosecutor has to prove. Under (A)(1)(a), the State must prove your ability to drive was impaired. Under a per se subsection, the State must prove a valid test result at or above the limit, whether or not you drove poorly.

The State’s burden under (A)(1)(a)

The statute says no one may drive if “the person is under the influence of alcohol, a drug of abuse, or a combination of them.” To convict, the State must show:

  1. You operated a vehicle in Ohio.
  2. Alcohol, drugs, or both impaired your ability to drive at that moment.

No test number is needed. The State builds this charge from the officer’s account of your driving, your speech, field sobriety tests, and anything recorded on dash or body camera. That also means a driver can be charged under (A)(1)(a) with a result under .08, or with no test at all.

The State’s burden under a per se subsection

Division (A)(1)(d), for example, prohibits driving with “eight-hundredths of one gram or more but less than seventeen-hundredths of one gram by weight of alcohol per two hundred ten liters of the person’s breath.” The State must prove:

  1. You operated a vehicle in Ohio.
  2. A sample was collected within three hours of the alleged violation.
  3. The sample was tested under Ohio Department of Health rules, on a properly maintained instrument, by a qualified operator.
  4. The result met the threshold for that subsection.

Per se cases are won and lost on the test. When the timing, the instrument records, or the operator’s permit do not hold up, the result can be challenged and sometimes kept out of evidence.

Low-Tier vs. High-Tier OVI: Where the .17 Line Falls

The dividing line is .17. A result of .17 or higher in blood or breath (or .238 in urine) moves the charge into subsections (A)(1)(f) through (i), known as high tier, and the mandatory minimums rise.

Division (A)(1)(h) bars driving with “seventeen-hundredths of one gram or more by weight of alcohol per two hundred ten liters of the person’s breath.” On a first offense, the minimum rises from three days in jail (or a three-day drivers’ intervention program instead) to three days in jail plus the program, or six days in jail.

High tier also affects driving privileges. When a judge grants limited privileges to a high-tier offender, the court must order restricted yellow license plates. Ohio courts cannot ignore these minimums, so a test result that lands at .168 or .172 matters a great deal. Our page on the penalties attached to each tier covers the full sentencing picture.

How Does Refusing a Test Change the Charge?

On its own, refusing a chemical test is not a crime in Ohio. It triggers an administrative license suspension (ALS) under ORC 4511.191, starting at one year for a first refusal, and the prosecutor may use the refusal as evidence at trial.

Refusal becomes its own offense under division (A)(2) when the driver has a prior OVI conviction within 20 years, was driving under the influence, and refused after arrest and after “being advised by the officer in accordance with section 4511.192 of the Revised Code of the consequences of the person’s refusal or submission to the test or tests.”

An (A)(2) conviction is sentenced like high tier. The mandatory jail time on a second offense doubles from 10 days to 20. On a third, it moves from 30 days to 60.

License suspension after a refusal

The ALS for refusal grows with each prior refusal or OVI in the last 10 years: one year, then two, then three, then five. The Ohio BMV lists suspensions for a positive test starting at 90 days.

An ALS can be appealed at the first court appearance or within 30 days after it, which is one of the earliest decisions in any case.

Do not let the 30-day window close. Call The Farrish Law Firm, L.P.A. at +1 (513) 549-0611. We answer 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

When Does a 4511.19 Charge Become a Felony?

BBB Accredited Business A+ Rating

A 4511.19 charge becomes a fourth-degree felony when the driver has three or four prior OVI convictions within 10 years, or five or more within 20 years. It becomes a third-degree felony when the driver has any prior felony OVI, “regardless of when the violation and the conviction or guilty plea occurred.”

The 10-year look-back comes from Annie’s Law, which took effect in 2017 and replaced the old six-year window.

Offense level Mandatory jail (low tier / high tier or refusal) Fine range Court license suspension
First in 10 years 3 days or 3-day program / 6 days $565 to $1,075 1 to 3 years
Second in 10 years 10 days / 20 days $715 to $1,625 1 to 7 years
Third in 10 years 30 days / 60 days $1,040 to $2,750 2 to 12 years
Fourth-degree felony 60 days / 120 days $1,540 to $10,500 3 years to life

On a fourth-degree felony, the judge may add a prison term of six to 30 months. A third-degree felony OVI carries the same mandatory minimums. In either felony case, a repeat-offender specification can add one to five mandatory years. Our Ohio repeat and felony DUI/OVI defense lawyers can explain how these cases are defended and what options may reduce that exposure.

Drug and Marijuana OVI Under 4511.19(A)(1)(j)

Division (A)(1)(j) makes it illegal to drive with certain drugs in your system at or above set levels, even with no sign of impairment. It covers amphetamine, cocaine, heroin, LSD, marijuana, methamphetamine, PCP, and several of their metabolites.

A metabolite is what the body leaves behind after breaking a drug down. For marijuana, the limits are 2 nanograms per milliliter of blood or 10 in urine. The metabolite limits are higher, and the lower metabolite limit applies only when the State also proves impairment.

This is where drug OVI cases get technical. Marijuana metabolites can stay in the body long after any effect has worn off. Ohio lawmakers have debated changing the marijuana limits, so the version that applies to your case is the one in effect on the date of the arrest.

4511.19(B) for drivers under 21

Division (B) is Ohio’s under-21 offense, often called OVUAC. It applies to drivers under 21 with a blood or breath result of .02 to under .08. It carries lighter penalties than an (A) charge, but it still brings a license suspension. Our Cincinnati underage DUI lawyers handle these cases and can explain what the charge means for a young driver’s license.

How Kelly Farrish Reads a 4511.19 Citation

The first thing we check is which subsection the officer wrote down. That tells us whether the case turns on the test or on the officer’s observations.

Kelly Farrish has been licensed in Ohio since 1979. He has been selected as an Ohio Super Lawyer in the DUI field every year from 2016 through 2025, and he speaks at the Ohio State Bar Association’s annual DUI seminar.

On a per se charge, we request the breath test result printout, the instrument’s calibration and maintenance records, the operator’s permit, and the time the sample was collected. On an (A)(1)(a) charge, we ask for the cruiser and body camera video and compare it line by line with the officer’s report.

We also review the BMV 2255 form, the officer’s report that starts the ALS. Errors on that form can support an ALS appeal. The Farrish Law Firm, L.P.A. brings decades of combined experience to these reviews.

Want someone to read your citation with you tonight? Call +1 (513) 549-0611. Free phone consultations are available.

Questions About Ohio’s OVI Statute

Can I be charged under 4511.19 if I was asleep in my parked car?

Usually, no. Ohio defines “operate” as causing or having caused a vehicle to move. A driver found asleep behind the wheel of a parked car is more likely to face a physical control charge under ORC 4511.194. That is a separate, lesser offense with no mandatory jail term.

Can a 4511.19 charge be reduced to reckless operation?

Sometimes. A reduction to reckless operation under ORC 4511.20 can happen through negotiation, most often when the test evidence or the stop has weaknesses. No lawyer can promise a reduction, and whether one is possible depends on the court, the prosecutor, and the evidence in your case.

Can a 4511.19 conviction be sealed or expunged in Ohio?

No. Ohio’s record-sealing law does not allow OVI convictions to be sealed, and a conviction adds six points to your Ohio driving record. A dismissal or acquittal is a different matter. Our page on whether a DUI can be expunged explains the options when a case ends without a conviction.

Does a DUI from another state count as a prior under 4511.19?

Yes. Ohio counts DUI convictions from other states as equivalent offenses when it looks back 10 or 20 years. A Kentucky or Indiana DUI can turn an Ohio first offense into a second. Our lawyers for out-of-state DUI/OVI charge cases can explain how these records are matched.

Talk Through Your Subsection With a Cincinnati OVI Defense Attorney

The Farrish & Nicholas Law Firm Attorneys

The subsection on your citation shapes the defense from the first day. Bring the citation to your call and we can tell you which subsection applies, what evidence to request, and what deadlines are already running.

Reach a Cincinnati OVI defense attorney at +1 (513) 549-0611. We defend you, 24/7. Payment plans are available, and the firm accepts major credit cards.

Cincinnati Defense Lawyer Kelly Farrish

ATTORNEY KELLY FARRISH

Kelly Farrish always knew he wanted to be an attorney, but he the path he took to get there isn’t like most. He served five years in the United States Air Force and did two voluntary years in South Vietnam. When he returned to Cincinnati, he worked the midnight shift as a technician at Cincinnati Bell, all the while attending college full time year round for three years. He graduated Cum Laude from the University of Cincinnati. [ ATTORNEY BIO ]

Free Consultation

Don’t wait to call. Request your FREE consultation. We defend you, 24/7.

    Divider Icon, Cincinnati DUI Attorney Kelly Farrish

    "His years of experience and knowledge were clearly evident and un-refutable. From the moment we met him we had absolutely no doubt that we had complete professionalism at our service and we could not have chosen a more qualified attorney."

    rating

    "I had a number of charges and ended up getting acquitted of all of them. I truly believe his knowledge and persistence is what got me through this case. I am very grateful and highly recommend him for his services."

    rating

    "I highly recommend Mr. Farrish. He is very thorough and is well liked by all of the courts. A genuine attorney and you couldn't find a better in the area."

    rating

    "The absolute best DUI lawyer in the tri state. Just short of a miracle worker"

    rating
    How to Choose an Ohio Criminal Defense Lawyer

    Every criminal defense attorney's website in Cincinnati makes similar claims. Big promises, bold language, stock photos of courthouses. None of that tells you whether a lawyer fits your case. Choosing an Ohio criminal defense lawyer requires looking past marketing. The factors that actually affect your outcome are the attorney's familiarity with your charge type[...]